The brutal killing of many innocent Sikhs across India in 1984 is still a burning subject after more than 30 years. It is indeed an extremely sad era for the entire Sikh Community being not able to get natural justice for the victims. This clearly indicates that the Sikh Community lacks on its resources to make an impact. The tragedy of genocide leaves many trails for us to ponder about as to what caused this tragedy?
It is obvious that the entire Sikh Community and our Sikh-leadership failed not only to avert the massacre by not intervening with courage, strength and numbers to curb the root cause in the first place. We failed as a Community to convince either of the warring parties to avoid the showdown. The Sikh President of India, Akali Dal, SGPC, Punjab Sikh Political leadership, other high ranking Sikhs in the government and Generals in the defence force either they kept quite or they had a no say to stop the Operation Blue Star. The saddest part is that the entire Sikh Community stood as a silent spectator and no forceful voice was raised or protest made in public to ask their Sikh members occupying the Akal Takhat to go out of the premises for its sanctity in the first place.
The Government of India was certainly ill-advised on the consequences of damaging the Darbar Sahib. The result was a war between two un-equals, which resulted in a colossal loss of lives and in the destruction of Sikh heritage.
One can draw some guiding conclusions and directions to learn from:-
1.Leadership/Direction: The Sikh Leadership is extremely poor and lacks courage and so are the Sikh masses who are responsible for putting them in positions of governance.
In support of partition of India, the Sikhs lost the most as compared to the Hindus. The Muslims were the clear winners. Later a large Punjab was broken into a smaller Punjabi Suba (current Punjab) at the pressure of the poor Sikh Leadership. Please do not again ask for a separate state or country for the Sikh – it is going to be another disastrous loss for the Sikhs. There are people sitting comfortably outside India who can easily air their views without weighing the consequences.
The collective Sikh leadership and the community have failed to get justice for the families of victims of 1984 is a clear indication that we do not have a powerful voice and also do not have numbers to shake the decision makers in a democracy where vote of each individual counts? In order to bring clarity of thinking and courage, we need to turn to our Guru-Guru Granth Sahib to inculcate leadership qualities, courage and cooperation within the Community and the rest of Humanity.
2. Management Skills: Managing Committees of Gurduars are run in a stereotype fashion by mostly ignorant Sikhs who use these platforms to further look for seats as Municipal Commissioner, MLAs, MP, State Governorship etc. The Sikhs are unable to govern Indian historic Gurdwaras as a single Body such as SGPC, Amritsar. Delhi- and recently Haryna-Gurdwaras are run by separate committees with absolutely no links and cooperation with one and other and rather they confront each other.
3. Education/language/literacy: The once prestigious Sri Guru Teg Bhadur Khalsa Higher Secondary School in Delhi has currently many sections of classes without a single Sikh student. Outside Punjab, the normal conversation between the Sikh parents & grandparents with their siblings is in a language other than in Punjabi. Even in Chandigarh (capital of Punjab), the Punjabi was not recognized as a second language until recently. What a pity for the Sikh-Community to be so helpless!
I visited the library of Sisganj Gurduara in Delhi recently and found it worst than a library in a middle level school in Delhi. I talked to the Management and later wrote a letter to the President of Delhi SGMC but was told that it was not on their priority. What a sad status of the leadership? The libraries attached to Bangla Sahib and Rakabganj Gurduaras are in worse state.
All the monthly magazines brought out by SGPC and DSGMC are stereotype. ‘Gurmat Parkash’ is good but the writings do not address the curiosity of our younger generation. With the result young minds are drifting to other beliefs which sound logical to them. There is an urgent need for well stacked ‘Gurmat-libraries in India and overseas with modern internet facilities to carry out research and stay abreast with Inter-faith dialogues’.
4. Proficiency in Gurbani: We do not promote learning of Gurmukhi Script and Punjabi language seriously. It will not be very far when the so called Sikhs will not be able to communicate to their Guru and the Guru Granth Sahib will be a silent idol. Most Sikhs anyhow are unable to read the Guru Granth Sahib and few of those who can read, cannot understand fully. Reading and reciting from the Guru Granth Sahib has become a specialist’s task. While the Sikhs still show great devotion to the Guru Granth Sahib and spend long hours listening to the Kirtan, but in the majority of cases, the intellectual understanding of the Gurbani and Sikh philosophy is truly abysmal.
The scriptures are becoming inaccessible to the younger generations because of the language used. The Khalsa Schools in Delhi, which were once primarily started to cater for Sikh students’ to learn Gurmukhi are not patronized any more. The Sikh parents want their children to study in public or other schools.
5. Sikh Identity: Generally an adherent of the Sikhism is called as a Sikh – one who is looking up to the Guru Granth Sahib as Guru even when he/she may be imperfect. Thus a Sikh could be: Amritdhari, Keshdhari, (Punjbi & non-Punjabi, Indians, Europeans, Americans, and Africans etc.), Sehajdhari sikh, gora or kala sikh and the list can go on. Since they are striving to be Sikhs, they are equal and deserve respect and all doors be kept open to all those who call themselves “Sikhs”. Guru Gobind Singh Ji provided water for enemy soldiers in the battle field and here we fail to accept or embrace those as Sikhs who are moving towards the Guru Granth Sahib, the most important Rehat Maryada for a Sikh.
The three virtues or pillars of the Sikhism: Nam Japna (comes from understanding of Gurbani –promotes 100% literacy); Kirt Karni (promotes professionalism) and Vand ke Chakhana (promotes Seva/ charity). The serious promoters of these qualities ‘Sikhs’ will certainly make good citizens of the World and shall promote spirituality, peace and prosperity wherever they will be- to help create ‘Khalistan’- a land of good people with sharing their resources.
6. Political Scene: In India, as we all know that there is a sharp divide between the Sikhs and Hindus (particularly the RSS) and the resentment with the majority community is ever widening. At political level, where number counts, the Sikhs are at almost even numbers with non-Sikhs in the Punjab State. The Sikh votes are predominantly divided in to two Camps: the Shromani Akali Dal (SAD) and Congress. With the growing number of migrant workers settling in Punjab, the days are not far away when the BJP, main Hindu political Party can easily take over the political control to run Punjab Government throwing SAD in the background altogether. If once BJP takes over on its own, the reversal of political process may not be easy. To remain in control in Punjab the Sikh community needs to boost its numbers or those who have strong allegiance to the Sikhs.
The Sikhs are anyway drifting away to various Deras, Babas and Yogis who are also promoting Gurbani but accept both the turbaned and non-turbaned Sikhs and non-Sikhs alike. The proposition is to suggest to open the doors and to accept those who have faith and trust in the Guru Granth Sahib (Gurbani) as the Sikhs. Guru Gobind Singh Sahib gave us the suffixes of `Singh’ and `Kaur’ after our names. But Guru Sahib nowhere said that those who do not have `Singh’ and `Kaur’ after their names are not Sikhs. Why cannot a George, Mary, Kamlesh, Rahman, Sharma, Christine, Joseph etc be Sikh names as well (Bhai Dr. Harbans Lal, USA is a living example)?
The future of Sikhs is too important to unfold on its own while we all passively wait. Certainly it cannot be left to some politico-religious Jathedars who may be great in their ceremonial functions but who may not be able to participate in any historical, philosophic or intellectual or even theological discourse. We need to build a Sikh Community with high ranking managers, diplomats, professionals, bureaucrats, entrepreneurs, politicians, scientists, economists, engineers, agriculturists, teachers, doctors, soldiers and sociologists, Sikhi /Gurbani Pracharaks ete etc.
In a democratic setup the numerical strength of a community matters. So there is a need to increase the number of Sikhs to a point that counts. We have to define the Sikh identity clearly taking in to account the ground reality. This requires a serious debate and setting up of an International Think Tank of the Sikhs and all those who have a commitment to turn to Guru Granth Sahib as Guru. This could be a serious discussion point for the various Sikh-Internet Groups as to how to give a shape to the Think Tank. The Sikh Diaspora in USA, Canada and UK should come forward to provide a base for technical and financial resources to bring about necessary changes by involving members of younger generations.
In the meantime, my appeal to all of you is to please do not accept even the second best people to run your local Gurdwaras/Sikh Institutions.
Kirpal Singh
Wellington, New Zealand
kirpal2singh@yahoo.com