The Sikhs are generally attached to their Gurduaras and respect them for providing a source of happiness in life through the Gurmat .
ਗੁਰੂ ਦੁਆਰੈ ਹੋਇ ਸੋਝੀ ਪਾਇਸੀ ॥ (Raag Soohee M. 1, GGS 730)
guroo dhuaarai hoe sojhee paaeisee |I
We all are intrinsically searching for divine virtues (truth, contentment, wisdom, sehaj and Naam) for sustenance in life as prescribed in Mundaavanee M.5 in the Guru Granth Sahib:
ਥਾਲ ਵਿਚਿ ਤਿੰਨਿ ਵਸਤੂ ਪਈਓ ਸਤੁ ਸੰਤੋਖੁ ਵੀਚਾਰੋ ॥ (Raag Mundaavanee M. 5, GGS.1429).ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤ ਨਾਮੁ ਠਾਕੁਰ ਕਾ ਪਇਓ ਜਿਸ ਕਾ ਸਭਸੁ ਅਧਾਰੋ ॥
The search for peace of mind takes us to Gurduaras, Deras , Babas, Sants and other enlightened persons. As a Sikh-child we learn a lot about Sikhi though our daily prescribed Ardas, which is simple to understand and talks about Waheguru, Gurus, Panj Piareys, Char Sahibzades, Chali Mukte, Shahid Singhs, Panj Takhats, places of worship (Gurduaras), remembrance of Waheguru’s name, seeking of Naam Daan and Naamis and sarbat da bhalla. The Ardas fills a child with a lot of goodness to look forward to see in life ahead.
As one grows as an adult one looks around in the family and in sangat to find there are hardly any or only a few (exceptions) who are truthful, contended, flowing with wisdom or who trust in Naam as saviour in life. The Managers of Gurduaras, Granthis, Bhais, one’s parents and relations (again with some exceptions) are in lip service only and are far from the virtues ordained in the Gurbani and in our daily Ardas. One thus finds oneself living in a Hippocratic environment. The more one meets with people over a period of time one tend to loose contact with reality and start flowing with masses.The result is that we are called as Sikhs but without a solid bond with Sikhi. So the first most important reason “Why do Sikh go to Deras and Babas” is lack of solid bond with Sikhi (Gurmat). Neither parents nor the so called leaders serve as role models to follow. This give rise to a certain degree of stress, insecurity, fears and loss of faith in old values. One starts looking for easy fixes while still superficially believing in the Gurbani. As a result entry into Gurbani based Deras remains a popular choice to look for alternative avenues.
New Deras come into the scene and thrive prominently in times of social, cultural and political stress such as era of excessive drug/alcohol consumption in society, sexual perversion, civil unrest (arising from discrimination based on caste, gender, language, beliefs in rituals etc.), turbulence and oppression arising from excesses of so-called spiritual leaders and government agencies (Occupation of Akal Takhat Sahib, Operation Blue Star and indiscriminate killing of Sikhs in 1984), threats posed by the majority community, rejection within one’s own community and due to changing life style in the society as promoted in media, TV and movies and trends portrait by show-biz etc.
Deras attract a disproportionate number of Sikh youths adults who lack self direction, purpose, and who need an external source of authority to provide a framework for their lives as parents have failed to guide them. Those who aimlessly drifting and disconnected can find instant comradeship and a sense of self-worth in a Dera. Lower working class are especially drawn to such Deras that feature emotional expression and magical aids to health, love, children, money, enticement and personalized attention.
There are Sikhs with conviction who attend meetings of Deras and Babas or listen to their discourses or read their publications just to compare notes and bring back the best from their experiences and stick solidly with their belief and faith in Gurbani/Gurduaras. I find myself in this category.
A group of Sikhs after satisfying their more basic needs for life and safety and security get concerned themselves with the actualization of their potential in other areas. Consequently, a significant portion of membership of Deras is made up of of members of the middle and upper middle class of the Indian society (including Sikhs) who are business people, medical doctors, lawyers and members of establishment. After having satisfied their primary needs of existence are looking for quick fixes to get some sort of enlightenment devoid of any rigidity in their chosen life styles by patronizing Deras and Babas (including Chinmaya Mission and Osho Commune).
All is not that well with Gurduaras. Most run routine programmes of reciting Gurbani, Keertans etc. with old music systems with not so good sound quality.There is no enlightened people available to explain the meanings through discourses understandable by simple people. There is hardly any continuity in programmes that compels a devotee not to break the sequence. Olden days there were Suraj Parkash Kathas (by Santhokh Singh Ji), which required daily presence to keep abreast with various episodes. Moreover, absence of any counselling service where people can seek advice to resolve their doubts/problems limits the roles of Gurduaras. Rituals which are openly denounced in Gurbani are practiced on daily basis. Status of women is compromised with their restrictive participation in the Gurduaras.
Whereas in Deras, the programmes are focussed and tailored according the needs of common people and include reciting of Gurbani, Keertans and discourses on selected Sabds in layman’s language so that a devotee learns something new on every visit. The so-called ‘patits’ are not only accepted but cared for. Langar seva is full of variety and serves tastes of all age groups. There is special care for handicapped and elderly people in entering/sitting in the main hall and langar hall. An added attraction offered by some Deras include Communes or Ashrams involving devotees in meditation and yoga as a tool for healthy development individually or in groups. Yogi Bhajan Ji thrived by combining spirituality with Yoga and attracted goras and kalas to become Sikhs.
Radhsoamis have discourses on selected Gurbani Sabds, Bani of Swamiji and of Sants like Kabirji (includes from outside GGS as well). Ravidassias focus on Bani of Bhaghat Ravi Dass Ji (froming part of GGS and his other compositions). I recently came across a set of 15 CDs on discourses by Sawan Singh ji (Radhasoami) from a Hindhu couple comprising of 10 on pure Gurbani Sabds, 4 on Swamiji bani and one on Baghat Kabir’s bani (not from GGS) translated into Hindi from the original punjabi version recorded at lest 5o years ago. These recordings present such a clear and vivid account which no modern Sikh kathakar has attempted to come close to in terms of clarity and simplicity in explaining the meanings.
Osho’s Deras (commune) focuses on discourses on selected Gurbani Sabds, writings of Kabir Ji, Palto Ji, Tulsi Das ji and other prominent saints and Sufis and enlightened persons of other religions including Budhism and christainity. A question-answer session conducted by Osho himself (when alive) or his current decedents is not only lively but adds extra value to their credit in imparting enlightenment in diverse areas of life, such as: ambition, anger, bliss, compassion, contentment, courage, creativity, death, desire, depression, education, ego, emptiness, fear, friendship, happiness, jealousy, life, love, lust, marriage, master, mind, music, prayer, relationship, religion, samadhi, sex, silence, suffering, surrender, truth and women etc.. As you know that a commentary of Japji Sahib by Osho is an excellent literary work by a non-sikh.
The Heads of Deras are well versed in Gurbani (that they talk about) and are charismatic in their approach. Devotees regard them as father figure and they are in turn available to provide advice and counselling on one to one basis when needed. Needy do get financial assistance directly from Heads of Deras or other members who are part of such a Deras. Gurduaras only collect funds and there is no provision to loan out funds to individuals when they desperately need.
Deras have become vote banks and politicians tend to extend support to Deras, which in return receive dividends from government agencies for claiming property and employment opportunities for family members of their devotees. Deras pay better salaries and give facilities (accommodation, transport) to their staff as compared to similar staff in Gurduaras. Admission to most Deraes is open to keshadharis, cleanshaven, those with or without turban or with or without cap and irrespective of one’s heritage by birth thus boosting the numbers of Deras going people..
Generally on joining a Dera, a devotee feels important and part of an elite group with enhanced social status and with possibility of some advantages arising from their close association with some wealthy and politically influential individuals. They foster a sense of community or group cohesiveness. They attend communal satsangs at the ashram as frequently as possible and help each other in case of emergency. Mutual cohesion takes the shape of a social club where the members share joy and sorrow together. All successful Deras offer ideas which are either richer, deeper, or more enigmatic and give free religious expressions suited to individuals personally. Such close interactions are missing in most Gurduaras other than in caste based Gurduaras.
People can and should attack Deras or Babas on real issues when they engage in illegal action such as fraud, kidnapping, coercion, violation of laws. Appropriate steps can or should be taken under criminal laws, irrespective of the claim of Deras or Babas. However, to blindly attack these groups poses a significant threat to civil liberties and our life styles. It is important to look at the issues in an unbiased way. If a bad Sikh joins a Dera and Baba and becomes a good man (good Sikh) it is good for the individual. But if a good Sikh joins a Dera to become a bad person, the Sikh Community should be concerned for such a drain.
The mainstream Sikhs on the other hand need to restore the dignity of their Gurduaras/Institutions by putting the right kind of people to run them with innovative programmes that are better suited to the needs of Sikh devotees of all ages in order to develop and foster a deep sense of belonging and unity in the entire community with a common thread of “Gurmat” as enshrined in the Guru Granth Sahib – “Tu ghat ghat anter sarab niranter ji, har eko purak samana”.
Personally, I have not visited or associated with any Dera or Baba (except Baba Iqbal Singh of Baru Sahib in his capacity as a Gurmukh Chancellor of the Eternal University). On my return to India (after a span of 38 years), I watched discourses of various Deras and Babas on TV with interest. All the discourses helped me to strengthen my conviction about Sikhi rather than they shaking or diluting it.
Kirpal Singh
Wellington, New Zealand
kirpal2singh@yahoo.com